5 Challenges of Being a Guitar Teacher
Guitar teaching

5 Challenges of Being a Guitar Teacher

A light-hearted look at attention spans, practice habits, budget guitars, tuning troubles, and the songs every guitar teacher knows by heart.

Published 08 September 2021• Updated 06 September 2026• By Matthew Rusk
Guitar TeachingGuitar TeachersTeaching ChallengesStudent EngagementMusic PracticeBeginner Guitars

Don’t get me wrong, I love my Job. Seeing someone go from playing the first few tentative notes of Smoke On The Water to shredding their way through Purple Haze is one of the most rewarding things in life, BUT, being a guitar tutor in 2017 does present some problems....

1 Attention span in lessons

You do get the sense that technology and millions of ever-increasing brain-clogging stimuli that steals your pupil’s attention on a regular basis. (I sound like an old man, I’m only 24, I promise).

Recently I have found that my lessons are run on a basis of intervals where every 10 to 15 minutes, guitar playing is replaced by joke telling and reciting of the school day’s events. It’s either this or you find some way of turning learning guitar into some strange gobbledygook with some hidden tab reading/guitar tips.

2 Getting your students to practice

When the Playstation is sat in the corner calling you to find that last egg on Spyro The Dragon (again I am 24, honest), you can see why picking up your guitar and stretching your hand beyond reason into the perfect C major, putting yourself through agony (worse than doing the splits apparently) doesn’t seem the most appetising idea in the world.

You need to engage your students in something that they really want to learn, tell them that their mates will lose their mind if they hear them play sweet child of mine, give them some incentive. That the cool girl in the year above likes guitar...

3 Argos budget guitars

OKAY... compared to all other problems... forget the actual teaching itself, forget the lazy students... the real bane of a guitar teachers life is that horrible, nylon strung, ply wood, thick necked monstrosity with strings that sit about 3 miles away from the neck. Not even Jimi Hendrix himself could play a solo on that thing...

And this is what young students get to learn on 9 times out of 10 because they’re affordable and advertised as being a first guitar and THEY’RE PRACTICALLY UNPLAYABLE.

So you let them play your American Strat for the lesson... WHAT ABOUT WHEN THEY GO HOME!? Then they’re left trying to play that amazing run from stairway to heaven on a piece of cardboard with strings floating 12 foot above it!

4 Every Apple Does Go Bad Eventually

A mild frustration linked to cheap guitars. Teaching your student to tune their guitar, tuner or no tuner, seems physically impossible until it one day just clicks. Keeping your cheapo ply wood guitar in tune is another matter, an eternal struggle between the powers of tunefulness and the gremlins of weak and flimsy tuning pegs.

Until then you are in a perpetual fight against the fact that as soon as your student gets home everything they play probably sounds dreadfully out of tune. Why can’t guitars stay tuned!?

5 Ed Sheeran

DISCLAIMER : I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH ED, in fact, I have the upmost respect for what a Suffolk boy and a little acoustic guitar have achieved. He’s more famous than the queen for god sake BUT teaching the same D, F#, G, A, D chord structure for Thinking Out Loud for the tenth time is a bit of a arrrrrrgh moment.

All-in-all, I actually quite like teaching guitar: it’s a journey, I’m sure most teachers feel the same! It has its flaws like any job, but when it goes well, and you’re jamming along playing the blues with someone half your size, it’s all worth it.

Recommended reads

Browse all →

Next reads based on shared topics and recently updated articles.

Summary

Teaching guitar is hugely rewarding, but it comes with a few recurring frustrations. Here are five challenges many guitar teachers will recognise.

Keeping students engaged
Short attention spans and competing distractions mean lessons often need variety, humour, and regular changes of pace.
Encouraging practice
Students are more likely to practise when they learn music they care about and have a clear reason to keep going.
Working with beginner gear
Cheap, difficult-to-play guitars and unreliable tuning can make early progress much harder than it needs to be.
Trustpilot reviews

Real Reviews from Parents & Students

Recent Trustpilot feedback from parents, adult learners, and teachers using MusicTeacher.com.

4.7
/ 5
Excellent on Trustpilot
Based on 31 published reviews
Read all reviews on Trustpilot
Matt Sofianos is an excellent teacher!
Matt Sofianos review
5.0

Matt Sofianos is an excellent teacher. His knowledge, patience and enthusiasm are infectious. I have been playing guitar for over 10 years and have learnt so much with him in the last year, far more than in the...

Tony
GB · Apr 10, 2026
Trustpilot
Amazing teacher brought both my sons to grade 8
Andrea Basiola review
5.0

Andrea Basiola is an amazing teacher who brought both my sons from zero to grade 8, one electric and one acoustic guitar. Patient, methodical and an amazing guitarist. Highly recommended.

Konstantinos Dimopoulos
GB · Mar 26, 2026
Trustpilot
An Amazing Music Personality
Mr Amenyah review
5.0

I encountered Mr Amenyah about 6 years ago and his patience and approach to teaching and leading songs is unique and superb. I call him Choir Master 1 and he calls me Soprano 1. He is a go to at anytime and will always...

Dorcas Kokobealowe
GH · Mar 21, 2026
Trustpilot
Tom Hier Singing Teacher
Tom Hier review
5.0

I have been having lessons with Tom for the past few years now, and he has been consistently brilliant. He was my biggest help in recovering from my tonsillectomy and strengthening my new voice. He helped me through...

Reece Morris
GB · Updated Mar 18, 2026
Trustpilot
Adult learner with history of giving up!
Rowena review
5.0

As an adult learner who has already abandoned several other instruments, Rowena has really helped foster a love of learning cello and an enthusiasm to keep going. She is creative in helping me find the music I want to...

nicola turner
GB · Mar 17, 2026
Trustpilot
Mr Kwabla Amenya is an awesome musical coach
Mr Kwabla Amenya review
5.0

Mr Kwabla Amenya is an awesome musical coach. I like how practical his teachings are. He is also patient and would repeat again and again until you get it.

Sweet wil
GH · Mar 16, 2026
Trustpilot
Guitar lessons with James Pusey
James Pusey review
5.0

My 15 year old son has been having lessons with James for around 3 years and has achieved his grade 1 and 2 in classical guitar and is now working towards grade 2 in acoustic guitar. The lessons take place in James's...

Catherine Marshall
GB · Mar 16, 2026
Trustpilot
Recommended Guitar Teacher
James review
5.0

James was recommended to me by my son's piano teacher. My son, age 13, has been having lessons in classical guitar with James for around 6 months and is very much enjoying his lessons. He looks forward to them and is...

Susie O'Reilly
GB · Mar 16, 2026
Trustpilot
brilliant and thoughtful teacher
Andy review
5.0

Brilliant and thoughtful teacher. My son's playing has significantly improved since learning with Andy and he is also an all round great guy.

Paul Wilkins
GB · Mar 13, 2026
Trustpilot
My son has been learning with Andy for years
Andy review
5.0

My son has been learning with Andy for over three years and absolutely loves his lessons. He really responds to Andy's teaching style and loves the music he picks. His guitar lesson is a highlight of his week.

Alice Boyd
GB · Mar 13, 2026
Trustpilot
Andy is an excellent and imaginative teacher
Andy review
5.0

Andy is an excellent and imaginative guitar teacher who has taught our son for three years now. During this time he has really brought the instrument to life for our son and this has coincided with a much wider interest...

JW
GB · Mar 13, 2026
Trustpilot
Absolutely amazing
Andrea review
5.0

Andrea was my guitar teacher for 8 years. He helped me prepare up to grade 5 in ABRSM. He was amazing in practising pieces and preparing me for exams and concerts. His lessons were fun and I always looked forward to...

Amrit Sinha
GB · Mar 13, 2026
Trustpilot
Andrea is an excellent and dedicated guitar teacher
Andrea review
5.0

Andrea is an excellent guitar teacher. He's taught my son from the ages of 7 to 15 and has the ability to relate to the student at different ages. He is also very patient. My son accomplished his ABRSM grades...

Rum Raisin
GB · Mar 13, 2026
Trustpilot
Brilliant, talented teacher
Andy review
5.0

Andy is a brilliant teacher for our teenage daughter. He is seriously talented, able to teach her seemingly any piece she chooses with no notice. She loves her lessons and her technique has improved no end.

Claire
GB · Mar 12, 2026
Trustpilot
Andy Basiola Guitar teacher
Andy Basiola review
5.0

I have been taking lessons from Andy for almost two years and in this time I have made such progress I did not expect. I improved drastically my legato and sweep picking, timing and picking hand tightness. He has both...

peppe testa
GB · Mar 12, 2026
Trustpilot
Superb teacher and mentor.
Tom review
5.0

Have been working with Tom for around a year now. He really knows his stuff. Material that felt completely impossible when I started he's made well within comfort. He has taught me an invaluable amount, both practically...

Bill
GB · Mar 11, 2026
Trustpilot
One of a kind!
Tom review
5.0

I've been working with Tom for about 10 years now, and the impact he's had on my life and career has been huge. He didn't just help me develop my voice as a singer, he helped guide me in the overall direction of my...

Matthew Callaghan
GB · Mar 11, 2026
Trustpilot
Tom Hier - Highly recommended singing teacher
Tom Hier review
5.0

Tom is a fantastic singing teacher who I'd highly recommend. I've been having lessons with him for about a year now, and the improvement I've felt has been brilliant, not just technically, but in my confidence as a...

K Eves
GB · Updated Mar 12, 2026
Trustpilot
Tom Hier incredible singing coach
Tom review
5.0

Tom is the best singing teacher I have met. I've been using his exercises for 4 years now which has helped me recover completely from vocal surgery. He is incredibly knowledgeable about singing technique and vocal...

Rubi
GB · Mar 11, 2026
Trustpilot
Best Singing Teacher
Tom review
5.0

Tom is the best teacher I've ever had. Efficient, knowledgeable, tailored exercises that have transformed my voice.

James
GB · Mar 11, 2026
Trustpilot
Good site for us tutors
Platform review
5.0

I am a tutor that has recently joined this site. I've been teaching piano, singing and music theory for many years and am used to unreliable students on other tutor websites cancelling last minute, not paying and not...

Rebecca Kintoff
PT · Mar 2, 2026
Trustpilot
Andy Basiola is a great guitar teacher
Andy Basiola review
5.0

Andy Basiola is a great guitar teacher. I've been taking lessons with him for many years and he is patient, knowledgeable and very competent.

Betty R.
GB · Feb 27, 2026
Trustpilot
Neil Morton - Outstanding Music Teacher
Neil Morton review
5.0

I have been taught by Neil Morton for many years. He is outstanding, patient, kind and highly knowledgeable in all aspects of music from theory to sight-reading and repertoire.

Mignon Mapplebeck
GB · Feb 22, 2026
Trustpilot
Mike Keane - Drum Teacher
Mike Keane review
5.0

Mike has been working with my two children since the start of the year, and they have had a wonderful time with him. He's extremely patient, very knowledgeable and is a warm, friendly presence as a teacher. Highly...

Chris
GB · Apr 22, 2026
Trustpilot
Mike Keane has been a wonderful teacher…
Mike Keane review
5.0

Mike Keane has been a wonderful teacher in the brief time I have spent learning how to play drums. He is a very patient person who always pushes me to the best of my current ability. A truly inspiring drummer to learn...

Harry Caiger
GB · Apr 22, 2026
Trustpilot
Michael Keane - Drum lessons
Mike Keane review
5.0

Mike has helped my son move from just playing for fun to actually understanding technique, timing, and proper practice routines. The online lessons work really well. Having the Google Meet link, shared folder, and...

Pete Thomas
GB · Apr 22, 2026
Trustpilot
Great Vocal Coach
Tom Hier review
5.0

I've worked with Tom during training and as a graduate. He was a great help in finding a thinner sound and offering exercises to smooth out mix and other registers. Efficient and also relaxed sessions.

Olly Adams
GB · Apr 19, 2026
Trustpilot
I have always wanted to play the guitar…
Danny Binnington review
5.0

I have always wanted to play the guitar so took up the courage to do something about it in 2020 but due to Covid we had to stop lessons for a while, which was disappointing. I have been learning with Danny for 4 years...

Mrs A nugent
GB · Apr 28, 2026
Trustpilot
I've been working with Tom for over 5…
Tom Hier review
5.0

I've been working with Tom for over 5 years now and always felt in very competent hands. He's not just a passionate teacher but also a great supporter, making lessons feel safe and comfortable. Always coming away with...

Asta
DE · May 11, 2026
Trustpilot
Amazing Vocal Coach
Kwabla Amenya review
4.0

Although I have only had two sessions with Mr Kwabla Amenya so far, I can already tell that he's a great coach. He determined what my weakness was and how to strengthen it, and I believe finding the exact problem is an...

Gertrude Galley
GH · Feb 21, 2026
Trustpilot
Swipe to browse recent Trustpilot reviews